Same offer, many engines. Judge two axes: art quality (light, realism) and brand/text control (real bag? exact Hebrew/price?). The winner is whatever clears both.
BEST FIT V2 · Gemini 3 Pro
Real Ambrosia bag + Hebrew in ONE image, photoreal dog. Hebrew reads correctly (model-rendered, not typeset). The only all-in-one that meets both hard constraints.
real bag · Hebrew · ~$0.27
BEST PRODUCTION V4 · Imagen4 Ultra + composite
Sharpest scene, real bag composited, PIXEL-PERFECT Hebrew (HTML overlay), deterministic + cheap to repeat. Only flaw: bag light slightly front-lit vs scene (Stability relight was blocked).
real bag · exact Hebrew · ~$0.10
LOOK ONLY V1 · gpt-image-1.5
Prettiest single-shot — but English text + AI-faked bag. Fails our real-product + Hebrew constraints. Good for concept/mood, not a shippable product ad.
fake bag · English · ~$0.07
DESIGNED V5 · HTML design engine
Real bag + perfect Hebrew + benefit pill, but a heavy magenta wash makes it read templated/pink. Cleanest brand layout, weakest photo.
real bag · exact Hebrew · $0
REJECTED V3 · FLUX Kontext
Best dog/scene, but TWO bags visible (real + hallucinated). Disqualified as-is. Fixable by feeding the real bag as input_image.
double-bag · ~$0.12
#1 Kling 2.1 Pro · I2V
Seeded from our hero frame → keeps the real product, smooth cinematic motion. Best generative option. 5s cap via fal (10s native).
#2 Veo 3 · T2V
Highest realism, full 8s — but invents its own dog/room, NO Ambrosia bag. Mood spot, not a product ad.
#3 HyperFrames
Deterministic motion-graphics. Pixel-perfect Hebrew + prices, zero hallucination, rebrandable in minutes. Production-safe, not cinematic.
#4 Runway Gen-4 Turbo
720×1280 upscaled, softer motion, lower bitrate. Weakest for this format.